|
Winter Light (1963, Swe.) (aka Nattvardsgästerna)
In director Ingmar Bergman's bleak and stark middle
film in his so-called "Absence of God" trilogy, including Through
a Glass Darkly (1961, Swe.) (aka Såsom i en spegel) and The
Silence (1963, Swe.) (aka Tystnaden) - an exploration and questioning
of religious faith and the problem of God's silence:
- the opening ritualistic scene in a small-town Lutheran
church in Mittsunda, Sweden during a soulless, wintry gray, mid-day
Sunday service conducted by the grim, widowed pastor Tomas Ericsson
(Gunnar Bjornstrand); the poorly-attended Holy Communion service
had only a total of five participants to receive the sacraments,
including the pastor's own romantic admirer and ex-mistress - eczema-afflicted
spinster and substitute school teacher Marta Lundberg (Ingrid Thulin),
the troubled, suicidal apocalypse-fearing fisherman Jonas Persson
(Max von Sydow) and his vulnerable, concerned pregnant wife Karin
(Gunnel Lindblom), the pastor's devout hunchbacked sexton Algot
Frövik (Allan Edwall), the church's clock-watching, impatient
organist Fredrik Blom (Olof Thunberg), and a few others
- the short scene, following the service, of disbelieving,
cold, grim, faithless and empty-souled, still-grieving pastor Tomas,
whose wife died four years earlier, not able to comfort and dissuade
the paranoid fears and dread of one of his parishioners - the suicidal
Jonas, who believed there would be a nuclear holocaust caused by
an atom bomb set off by Chinese Communists; he told the couple:
"It's so overwhelming, and God seems so very remote...I feel so
helpless. I don't know what to say. I understand your anguish, but
life must go on..."
- the visually-stark depiction of the anguished, tested,
detached and passionless pastor's crisis of faith, symbolically presented
when he looked up at the altar's sculpture of the Crucifixion and
thought to himself: "What a ridiculous image"
- the scene of the oft-rejected, unstable Marta attempting
to comfort the sickly, unloving pastor, and asking if he had read
the letter she had recently written to him - it had arrived the day
before; she spoke about her day and unrequited love for him: "Another
Sunday in the vale of tears...You should marry me...Then I wouldn't
have to leave this place...You can't marry me because you don't love
me"; she also affirmed her atheistic beliefs to him: "God
has never spoken because God doesn't exist. It's as simple as that"
- after she left, the intense, lengthy letter-reading
scene when Tomas read Marta's letter outloud to himself; the scene
included a single static close-up shot of her face as the letter
was read, implying how cruelly she had been treated by Tomas - mostly
for her skin rash affliction: ("We find it difficult to talk
to each other. We're both rather shy, and I tend to retreat into
sarcasm. That's why I'm writing. I have something important to say.
Do you remember last summer, when that awful rash broke out on my
hands? One evening, we were in church arranging flowers on the altar,
preparing for a confirmation. Do you recall what bad shape I was
in? My hands all bandaged, and itching so much I couldn't sleep?
The skin had flaked off, and my palms were like open sores. We busied
ourselves with daisies and cornflowers, or whatever they were, and
I was feeling irritable. Suddenly, I got mad at you and challenged
you angrily, asking if you actually believed in the power of prayer.
You replied that you did. In a nasty tone, I asked if you had prayed
for my hands, but it hadn't occurred to you to do so. I melodramatically
demanded that you do it then and there. Oddly enough, you agreed.
Your compliance enraged me, and I tore off the bandages. You remember
the rest. The sight of those open sores affected you greatly. You
couldn't pray. The entire situation disgusted you. I came to understand
you later, but you never understood me. We had lived together for
some time at that point. Almost two years, which at least represented
some capital in the face of our emotional poverty. Our caresses,
and our clumsy attempts to evade the lack of love between us. When
the rash spread to my forehead and scalp, I soon noticed how you
avoided me. You found me repugnant though you tried to spare my feelings.
Then the rash spread to my hands and feet. And our relationship ended.
That came as a shock to me. I had to face the fact that we didn't
love each other. There was no way to hide from that fact or turn
a blind eye to it. Tomas, I have never believed in your faith, mainly
because I've never been tortured by religious tribulations. My non-Christian
family was characterized by warmth, togetherness and joy. God and
Jesus existed only as vague notions. To me, your faith seems obscure
and neurotic, somehow cruelly overwrought with emotion, primitive.
One thing in particular I've never been able to fathom: your peculiar
indifference to Jesus Christ. And now I'm going to tell you about
answered prayers. Laugh if you feel like it. Personally, I don't
believe the two are connected. Life is messy enough without taking
the supernatural into account. You were going to pray for my weeping
hands, but the rash left you dumbstruck with repulsion, something
you later denied. I went beserk and tried to provoke you (she tore
off her bandages and prayed: 'God, why have you created me so eternally
dissatisfied, so frightened, so bitter? Why must I realize how wretched
I am? Why must I suffer so hellishly for my insignificance? If there
is a purpose to my suffering, then tell me so I can bear my pain
without complaint. I'm strong. You made me so very strong in both
body and soul, but you never give me a task worthy of my strength.
Give my life meaning and I'll be your obedient slave.' This autumn,
I realized that my prayers had been answered. I prayed for clarity
of mind and I got it. I realized that I love you. I prayed for a
task to apply my strength to, and I received one. That task is you.
This is what the thoughts of a schoolmarm might run to when the phone
refuses to ring, when it's dark and lonely. What I lack entirely
is the capacity to show you my love. I haven't a clue how to do that.
I've been so miserable, I've even considered praying some more. But
I still have a shred of self-respect left in spite of it all. My
dearest Tomas - this turned out to be a long letter, but now I've
put down in writing what I never dared say when you were in my arms.
I love you. And I live for you. Take me and use me. Beneath all my
false pride and independent airs, I have only one wish: to be allowed
to live for someone else. It's so terribly difficult. When I think
about it, I can't see how I will be able to pull it off. Maybe it's
all just a mistake. Tell me I'm not wrong, darling")
- the second private session shortly later between Tomas
and Jonas in the afternoon, when the pastor asked only a few superficial
questions, and then spoke mostly about his own confusions, spiritual
failures and despair, and growing disbelief in God, especially after
his wife's death: ("I'm no good as a clergyman. I put my faith
in an improbable and private image of a fatherly God, one who loved
mankind, of course, but me most of all. Do you see, Jonas, what a
monstrous mistake I made? An ignorant, spoiled, and anxious wretch
makes a rotten clergyman. Picture my prayers to an echo-God who gave
benign answers and reassuring blessings. Every time I confronted
God with the realities I witnessed, he turned into something ugly
and revolting. A spider-God, a monster...If there is no God, would
it really make any difference? Life would become understandable.
What a relief. And thus death would be a snuffing out of life. The
dissolution of body and soul...There is no creator, no sustainer
of life. No design"); even more depressed and uncomfortable
by the discussion, Jonas left without any reassurances, and subsequently,
it was reported that he had driven to the nearby river and shot himself
in the head with his rifle
- the scene of Tomas' cruel, tough, stern, berating
and pitiless criticisms of the self-deprecating Marta to her face,
triggered when she said to him in her apartment/schoolhouse building: "You
sound so unfriendly. Sometimes you sound as if you hated me" -
he bitterly described everything he detested about her: the humiliating
gossip generated by their relationship, the damage to his reputation,
her pitiful pleadings, her incessant talking, hysterical crying and
her constant attention to him, and most importantly: "The real
reason is that I don't want you...I'm tired of your loving care,
your fussing, your good advice...I'm fed up with your shortsightedness,
your clumsy hands, your anxiousness, your timid displays of affection.
You force me to occupy myself with your physical condition...I'm
sick and tired of it all, of everything to do with you"; he
also said she was an ugly parody and mimic of his deceased wife -
the only woman he had ever loved; he ended the conversation by grabbing
her: "Can't you be quiet? Can't you leave me alone? Can't you
just shut up?!"
- in the last major scene, the thoughtful and enlightened
conversation of the crippled, handicapped church sexton with Pastor
Tomas about the meaning of the Passion and Christ's suffering when
he was abandoned on the Cross - "Wouldn't you say the focus
on his suffering is all wrong?...This emphasis on physical pain.
It couldn't have been all that bad. It may sound presumptuous of
me - but in my humble way, I've suffered as much physical pain as
Jesus. And his torments were rather brief. Lasting some four hours,
I gather? I feel that he was tormented far worse on another level.
Maybe I've got it all wrong, but just think of Gethsemane, Pastor.
Christ's disciples fell asleep. They hadn't understood the meaning
of the Last Supper, or anything. And when the servants of the law
appeared, they ran away. And Peter denied him. Christ had known his
disciples for three years. They'd lived together day in and day out,
but they never grasped what he meant. They abandoned him, down to
the last man. He was left all alone. That must have been painful.
To realize that no one understands. To be abandoned when you need
someone to rely on. That must be excruciatingly painful. But the
worse was yet to come. When Jesus was nailed to the cross - and hung
there in torment - he cried out - 'God, my God! Why hast thou forsaken
me?' He cried out as loud as he could. He thought that his heavenly
father had abandoned him. He believed everything he'd ever preached
was a lie. In the moments before he died, Christ was seized by doubt.
Surely that must have been his greatest hardship? God's silence";
Tomas - who had been listening, simply answered in agreement: "Yes,
yes"
- Tomas' final words spoken from the Frostnas church
altar toward a silent and empty church - delivered during another
perfunctory and meaningless vespers service that afternoon with no
outside attendees except Marta: "Holy, holy, holy is the Lord
of Hosts. The whole earth is full of His glory"
|
|