|
Indiscreet (1958, UK)
In director Stanley Donen's sophisticated romantic
comedy, about the flirtations between an unhappily-married financier
and a single, middle-aged stage actress:
- the split-screen telephone conversation (pre-dating
the Doris Day/Rock Hudson Pillow Talk (1959) by almost a
year) in different hotel rooms between avowed, good-looking international
financier Philip Adams (Cary Grant) - unhappily married and separated
from his estranged wife and unable to get a divorce - and rich,
successful, middle-aged London theatrical stage actress Anna Kalman
(Ingrid Bergman)
- over a game of pool, the scene of Philip explaining
to Anna's brother-in-law Alfred Munson (Cecil Parker) his rationale
for pretending that he was a married man (but was not), to purportedly
make himself more of a "challenge" for some women because
he would then be regarded as unavailable - a unique form of chivalry:
("Let's just take a, well, a usual case. A man meets a woman.
He's attracted to her. He courts her. They're old enough, and she,
uh, favors him. Eventually she'd like to get married. He then says
I am not the marrying kind. Do you admire such a man?...Well, I,
too, don't care to be married. On the other hand, I don't care to
give up women....Now, since I have no intention of getting married,
I feel honor-bound to declare myself in the beginning...Certainly
before the favors. That's where the honor comes in. Now, how do I
declare myself? By saying I will never marry? What woman really believes
that? If anything, it's a challenge to them....Well, I say I am married.
I'm married, and I can't get a divorce. Now our position is clear.
There can't be any misunderstanding later...Well, it is reasonable");
but then, Philip added that he also felt true love for Anna: ("And
whether you believe it or not, I love Anna. I love Anna as I've never
loved before. But I wouldn't marry any woman if you held a gun to
my head")
- the scene of Anna's expression of anger and humiliation
to Alfred and his wife Margaret (Phyllis Calvert) (Anna's sister)
at being deceived about Philip's marital status - the film's main
plot twist: ("I was down on my knees asking his forgiveness
because I asked him to marry me. On my knees! How dare he make love
to me and not be a married man!"); she slammed the door shut
to her bedroom and threw her perfume bottle through her mirror (off-screen)
- Alfred's remark about the irony of the revelation:
("It's all very strange. It was perfectly all right when he
was married, when you'd think that it wouldn't be. And now that we
know that he's single, when it should be all right, if you know what
I mean, well, it isn't. Do you follow me?")
- the film's final consoling lines by Philip to a vengeful
and tearful Anna after he had proposed to her, but she had decided
that she wanted to remain 'unmarried' to him ("I mean we'll
go on as before") - she didn't believe they were fated for marriage;
however, because he was so emotionally shocked at her decision, he
was able to get her to change her mind: ("That's the most improper
thing I've ever heard.... I can hardly believe my ears....I didn't
think you were capable of it....We're not married....But you didn't
know I wasn't married.... I knew you didn't know. What's the
matter with you? How could you ask me to do such a thing? Haven't
you been following what I've been saying? Oh, I tell you, women are
not the sensitive sex. That's one of the great delusions of literature.
Men are the true romanticists....Don't cry, Anna, I-I love you. Everything
will be all right. You'll like being married. You will. You'll see.
Yes")
|
Split Screen Phone Conversation: Philip and Anna
Philip's Pool Game Discussion About His Marital Status
With Anna's Brother-In-Law Alfred
Anna's Anger At Being Deceived
Eventual Proposal of Marriage
|